At the August 25 Orange City Council meeting, City Manager Jarad Hildenbrand told the room that the old Sully-Miller quarry on Santiago Canyon Road had been "subject to development proposals, community debate, referenda and litigation" for decades. He called that night a chance "to begin writing a very different ending, one centered on restoration, preservation and ultimately, public permanent open space," as Voice of OC reported. The council approved the agreements that night.
For anyone shopping East Orange, that vote is one of three land decisions now underway within a short drive of each other along Santiago Canyon Road. One parcel is headed toward permanent open space. A second is approved for 22 large new homes. A third is proposed for 30 homes on small lots where horses train today. A home's value in this corner of Orange now depends on which of those three decisions it sits next to, and the ZIP-code median can't show that.
The roughly 67.7-acre Sully-Miller property at 6145 E. Santiago Canyon Road was mined for sand and aggregate from about 1919 to 1995. The city's August 2026 staff report traces what happened after the mining stopped:
Over more than three decades, the city kept facing the same question about this land, and every large housing plan for the main parcel failed. The planning documents had pointed the other way since the 1970s. According to the staff report, the Santiago Creek Greenbelt Plan and the Orange Park Acres Specific Plan both called for open space, trails and the rural character of the area. Orange Park Acres itself began in 1928 as a 640-acre subdivision, and its equestrian tracts were laid out on one-acre and some half-acre sites. New subdivisions kept arriving through the 1970s, from Grovewood in 1972 to High Horse Trails in 1979, and a multi-use trail system follows Handy Creek between properties, according to the Orange Park Acres Association.
Under the agreements, Landify ECT Construction Corporation would buy the property from Milan REI X, run an inert debris engineered fill operation and grading to set the final landform, and then convey the land to the city. The deed would carry a recorded restriction limiting it to permanent public open space and compatible public uses. The city pays no purchase price.
This deal adds to land already set aside along the creek. About 14 acres of the Chandler/Hurwitz property were preserved in 2024, and in January 2026 the city accepted about 30.75 acres on the northern part of the Sully-Miller site. If this transfer closes, the three pieces together come to roughly 112 acres along Santiago Creek, though they don't form one contiguous site.
For a buyer near the site, the open question is timing. Landify will own the land while the work goes on. Voice of OC reported on October 30 that arsenic had been found in portions of several soil stockpiles, and that removal of that material and more testing come before Landify's purchase. Hildenbrand told the outlet that Landify plans to cut back and rebuild stockpile slopes, build engineered support berms, and place new engineered fill under a compacted cover. He said the whole effort "should be viewed as a multi-year process," with no set timeframe for the open space.
The finished park comes later. Trails, equestrian facilities and habitat restoration are the city's to plan after it takes ownership, and none of them has a design or budget yet. The city plans to look for grants and partnerships to pay for them. In the same Voice of OC report, Sherry Panttaja, president of the Orange Park Association, is quoted telling the council the effort would add "significant value to the rural character of the surrounding area."
For a buyer, what the land will become is settled, and the schedule is what remains open. A home that looks out on the pit is buying a long-term open-space view, with grading and fill work to come first.
The agreement with Milan also covered two residential sites near the pit, so this corridor is changing faster than the open-space news alone suggests.
The first is Mabury Estates. The 22-home tract north of Santiago Creek, next to Mabury Ranch, was approved in 2020. According to the Foothills Sentry, Milan sold it to D.R. Horton in 2025. The builder lists the community as coming soon, with homes from 3,105 to 5,059 square feet, and it has not published prices. The 30.75 acres the city accepted in January surround this tract.
The second is the horse arena at 6146 E. Santiago Road, at the southeast corner of Santiago Canyon Road and N. Nicky Way. The Foothills Sentry reported in June on a proposal for 30 two-story single-family homes on the 7.4-acre site. Lots would run from 4,644 to 7,965 square feet, every home would have a two-car garage, and six of the homes would be affordable units. The plan includes private streets, common open space and an equestrian trail along the north and west edges. The produce stand, arena, training rings and paddocks would close. As of that June report, no Planning Commission hearing had been scheduled.
So within a short drive of each other, the corridor will have Orange Park Acres properties on one-acre and half-acre sites, 22 new homes up to about 5,000 square feet, 30 homes on lots under 8,000 square feet, and a protected creek corridor of about 112 acres. Each of those is a different product at a different price per square foot, all along one stretch of Santiago Canyon Road.
Orange County Register tables built on Attom data show how far a median can move in a ZIP that mixes acre lots with smaller tract homes. In June 2026, ZIP 92869 had 57 sales and a median of $1,062,500, according to the Register's September 22 report. In July 2026, the same ZIP had 22 sales and a median of $1,267,000, up 13 percent from July 2025, per the Register's October 30 table.
The July median came in about $200,000 above June's, on fewer than half as many sales. With 22 closings, the median depends on which homes happened to sell that month. A month with a few acre-lot horse properties and fewer smaller homes produces a high number, and a month with the opposite mix produces a low one. The other Orange ZIPs in the same July table show the same issue at smaller scale. ZIP 92867 posted $1,280,000 on 34 sales, and 92866 posted $1,290,000 on just six.
The countywide numbers are steadier and more current. According to the California Association of Realtors' September 2026 report, the median price for an existing single-family home in Orange County was $1,480,000 in September, up 5.6 percent from September 2025. The median time on market was 30 days, and there were 3.0 months of unsold inventory. That gives a buyer the pace of the wider market. It doesn't say what an acre on a trail near Santiago Creek is worth next to a new tract home a mile away. For that, the useful comparisons are recent sales of the same kind of property near the same kind of neighbor. Fullerton's high school boundaries and Yorba Linda's lake and golf pockets split their markets in a similar way.
Start with what borders the home. A parcel along the Sully-Miller edge now has a contracted path to permanent open space, something no earlier proposal for the site ever produced, with fill and grading work coming first. A home near Santiago Canyon Road and Nicky Way sits next to a proposal that would replace a working horse arena and produce stand with 30 homes, and that proposal had no hearing date as of the June report. A home in Mabury Ranch will soon have new construction nearby. Once D.R. Horton posts prices for Mabury Estates, those numbers will become the newest comparable sales in the area.
Sellers can work from the same map. An Orange Park Acres listing with trail access and an acre of land competes with a different set of buyers than the 92869 median suggests. Pricing it from the ZIP number puts it in competition with homes that buyers don't actually compare it to. The council's August vote gives that listing a factual point to include, along with its date and the city record behind it.
Is the Sully-Miller site a public park now? No. The city has approved a contract that leads to ownership. Landify would buy the land, finish the environmental and grading work, and then convey it once the closing conditions are met. City officials have described that as a multi-year process.
What happens to the land the city already owns there? The roughly 30.75 acres the city accepted in January 2026 surround the Mabury tract. They include conservation lands tied to that development, with conservation easements involving Rivers & Lands Conservancy and the California Department of Fish and Wildlife.
Will the arena-site homes look like the rest of Orange Park Acres? They would sit on much smaller lots. The proposed lots range from 4,644 to 7,965 square feet, with private streets, common open space and an equestrian trail along two edges.
If you own a home along the Santiago Creek corridor and want to know how the Sully-Miller agreement, Mabury Estates and the arena proposal affect what your property is worth, the Brad Kerr Team can price it against sales of similar homes next to similar land, not the ZIP average. Request a Free Home Valuation and we'll walk you through the comparable sales.
We provide the expertise, resources, and cutting-edge tools you need to navigate the real estate market with confidence. Whether you're buying or selling, we offer insights and solutions that set us apart. Stay informed about the latest market trends and let us guide you every step of the way.